Visiting with a Shadow

Ethan’s Dad: I still visit regularly, usually three days a week. For the first full year, I visited nearly every single day. I know some people think it is strange that I would go to Ethan’s grave so often. I suppose in their minds it seems like it would be too painful to visit such a place over and over again. But it is extremely important to remember, when supporting friends, neighbors, or loved ones who have sustained losses, that people grieve in different ways and they need to be given the space to do so. What I do is no better or worse, no more normal or weirder than how my wife seeks to survive in the midst of her grief. She visits his grave as well, though not as often, but she journals, for instance, much more frequently than I have. We are each dealing with an unexpected absence, a weight that may tug on our hearts more heavily at some times than others, but that always remains with us wherever we go. Yet we are different people and so our methods of carrying the weight correspond with our own personalities. And so it is with all who carry burdens of loss.

At first when I visited, I mostly talked to Ethan. I should clarify in mentioning this that it isn’t that I believe Ethan is there — at least not the part of him that matters most. My wife recently wrote a post about some of the awful day that was Ethan’s funeral. And while there was much that was unspeakably difficult about that particular day, one revelation for me occurred when we saw his little body in the tiny casket. We cried rivers of tears. We read letters to him that we placed in the casket. We hugged a lot. But one thing that was very apparent to me was that Ethan was not really there. His precious, frail body was there . . . but it was cold and impassive. . . the light of life was gone from it.

This is a difficult idea to put into words because it honestly can only be experienced, not exactly described, and yet it is not an experience I would wish for anyone. But in that tragic moment when you see your still baby who was so vibrant only a few days before, there comes this clear sense that something is truly amiss: You come face to face with the truth that a person is much more than just flesh and blood. People have spirits which make them who they truly are. The contrast between our real Ethan and what was left of him in that casket was so stark that this spiritual reality was undeniable. Our Ethan — the curious, quiet, lovable, strong, immaculately precious boy — is with the Lord. He is laughing now, rather than hurting, and waiting for us (though the wait will seem like nothing to him because time is nonexistent in heaven).

Alas, time is all too real to us, and to me it seems to go by much more slowly now than before Ethan’s passing. And so I choose to pass some of that time by sitting next to his grave. It is not the most vital part of him, but it is all we have left here in this in-between place we call the Shadowlands. It is my tangible connection to him. It is a place-holder until the joyous reunion.

Over time, my conversations with Ethan morphed into talking to God more often than talking to Ethan because He is my spiritual connection to Ethan. God is the reason a reunion will happen, made possible by Jesus’ sacrifice on the Cross. Jesus said He is “the Alpha and the Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End” — of all things. (Revelation 22:13). This means He is also the God of this off-kilter in-between time in which we find ourselves.

At times, walking in these shadows, it can seem as if He has abandoned us, left us to our own devices.

“I cried out to God for help;
I cried out to God to hear me.

“When I was in distress, I sought the Lord;
at night I stretched out untiring hands,
and I would not be comforted.

“I remembered you, God, and I groaned;
I meditated, and my spirit grew faint.”

(Psalm 77:1-3). In fact, that is one reason that at first I only talked to Ethan: Because I did not feel God there, all I felt was a black hole, a yawning abyss from which no light could emanate or escape.

But in the end, faith is not about feelings, it is about will, submission of the will really, but will nonetheless. And when you press on through the shadows you discover that there is light there after all.  (And how could it be otherwise?  For shadows are only seen because of the light that illuminates reality). The light is not a bolt that thunders, at least not for me, but a flicker that whispers your name and tells you to keep listening. And so the conversations become less and less audible and more and more reflections pouring over the Bible, His words that come alive because of His Spirit communing with our own when we seek Him.

I don’t mean for it to sound like magic. It is not. There is no trick and this is not fantasy land. I do not live in a state of Zen or blessedness or higher consciousness or whatever else some beliefs choose to call their willful blindness toward the tragedies of life. Nor do I mean to sound super-spiritual, for the contemplation is born from desperation, not holiness. I am weak. I am hurt. I still feel out of sorts. I still cry because of this inexplicable loss that neither Ethan nor we deserved to experience.

And so I sit next to the place where Ethan’s little body resides. I sit still in the quiet (there are few places quieter than a large cemetery).  And in that stillness I know that God is there (Psalm 46:10), and I dare to trust that Ethan is with Him, waiting. My heart yearns: Come quickly, Lord Jesus, Come. (Revelation 22:20).

The Toughest Questioners

His Mom: I have been delaying on writing my first blog post (other than my introduction of Ethan) for a few weeks now. It’s hard to know where to start, how much to say. I have a list of possible topics in my planner, and I was going to sit down and start one tonight, come heck or high water. I was trying to decide what to write about while rocking #4 to sleep tonight. Then this happened at bedtime…

We had been to the pool in the morning, and the kids were pretty tired by bedtime. Then we let them stay up a little late to get to a good stopping point in Muppets Take Manhattan, tonight’s family movie selection. After I got child #3 in bed upstairs, I came down to say good night to #1 and #2, having already been tucked in by Daddy. #1 informs me that #2 has been crying since Daddy left. She has moments of bedtime drama fairly frequently and tends to try to delay the process of being tucked in. But when I leaned down, I instantly realized this was not a little girl who was manipulating bedtime, or even just overly tired. This was a little girl genuinely upset about something. So I leaned down and asked her what was wrong. “I don’t want to tell you,” she replied. That is highly unusual. I replied that most times talking about something that is upsetting makes us feel better. She then had me lean in even closer to whisper in my ear, still shaking with little sobs, “I am afraid when you and Daddy die I won’t have anything to remember you by.”

Can you hear the sound of a mama’s heart breaking at this point in the story?
I have no way of officially knowing this, but I’d bet the farm we have more conversations about death and dying with our children than the average suburban American family. Deep questions are not unusual at bedtime, when the kids seem to get reflective and ask hard questions by the soft glow of their night light. Our kids ask why people put up stones in the yards around Halloween that look like the ones at “the place to think about Ethan,” which is our family’s term for his graveside. They ask if you get birthday cake in heaven. They want to know why his heart stopped. For several weeks last year, #1 would lose it at bedtime because he wanted to know how old Ethan would be when we see him again – does he grow up in heaven or stay a baby? The answer he came up with was that Ethan would be older than him, which negated his role as the oldest child and upset him greatly. Just the other day, #3 asked when Ethan was coming back from heaven. They know that butterflies and dragonflies start out as caterpillars and water bugs before their bodies are transformed into new bodies, just like people when they die and go to heaven.

I hate that they know so much, that their childlike innocence is marked by this terrible tragedy. I hate that they have been to a cemetery way more times in the last year than I had been in my first 36 years of life combined. We can’t tell them that people don’t ever die until they are old. We can’t promise that someone else in our family won’t die. They would see right through those answers in a second.

I asked what had been making her think about mommy and daddy dying, and she confirmed that she had been thinking about Ethan. I assured her that anytime you love someone, you will never, ever forget them. Even if she didn’t have any mementos, she would never forget us and we would never forget her. Because our “fancy Nancy” loves her some jewelry, I followed up with a promise that she would get to keep one of my special necklaces to wear. “What about Daddy? What does he have that we can keep?” We came up with his collection of National Park quarters and his Nebraska baseball cap. The hat seemed to satisfy her (again, an accessory!) and she laid back down. Two seconds later, she popped back up with a question about Muppet Babies, so I felt okay moving on with goodnights and backrubs and admonitions to be quiet and get some sleep.
Then I stood outside their door, clutching my chest and asking God to keep my little girl from having nightmares about her parents dying.

Do you know what makes these Q&As even worse than they already are? I want to know that answers to the same questions and more. I ask myself every.single.day why Ethan’s heart stopped. Why do people have to die? Why does God heal some people and not others? I want to know if he is eating ice cream or smiling or getting to know his amazing great-grandparents. I sure hope so. Outwardly, I am telling my son that we don’t know what Ethan will look like or how old he will be when we see him again, but we do believe the Bible promises we will recognize him. Inwardly, my chest is burning and the voice in my head is shouting “that’s not enough! I want to know what he looks like now, what he will look like then, and how in the world can You possibly make this all right in the end?”

You would not leave your child at a daycare sight unseen, not even one recommended highly by most of your friends and family. You want to see the room they will be in every day, meet the workers who will hold and change your baby while you are gone, and verify their security systems and check out processes. Even then, sending them on that first day is hard, even if they are too little to raise a fuss.

On March 10th, 2017, my child was abruptly taken to a place I cannot go, where people can’t send text messages or make Facetime calls. Even worse than not knowing anything about the place, I don’t even know anything about him anymore. It is so horribly, wrenchingly sad and scary.

I tell myself that he is with God, and that God is Love. He is known and loved and cherished by Jesus, as much or more so than if he were here on earth. If the stories are true, he is in the best and safest place he could be. It hurts my heart a little that there could be a place better or safer than in my care, but if that were not true, I would be in utter despair. As it is, we walk this weary road, trudging ever closer to the day when death shall be no more. God will wipe every tear from our eyes, and at last I won’t have any more questions to answer.